Wordpress 2.7.1, cforms 10.5.2

I'm attempting to create a form that will submit to different people based on choices from a drop down menu.  I've read through the documentation (about 100 times) and looked here on the forums to see if I can sort out what the issue is, but have been unable do figure it out. 

I have created a form here: http://trustco.simclient.com/contact-us/

When submitting the form, all people listed in the Admin email addresses fields recieve emails.  I have a dropdown input field with these values in it:

And the following in the email address fields:

Things I've tried:

1. No spaces in email addresses
2. completely different email addresses
3. Nameing the field "Multiple Recipients"
4. Adding corrensponding email addresses as the optional values being sent
5. Upgrading to the latest version of cforms

Nothing seems to work properly.  Any help would be greatly appreciated.